Follow us on Google News
Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed
SPOILER ALERT: The Article Contains Spoilers forOppenheimer
Christopher Nolan’s new biopicOppenheimeris facing intense criticism over a shocking fictional scene suggesting brilliant physicist J. Robert Oppenheimer once attempted murder. Oppenheimer’s own grandson has publicly denounced the violent moment as completely fabricated and an act of slander that irrevocably taints his grandfather’s name. This latest controversy only furthers the debate around Hollywood biopics blending fact with fiction when dramatizing real people’s lives.
With its fictional murder plot line,Oppenheimerhas angered scientists and historians in addition to Oppenheimer’s family. Many argue that putting clearly invented words and actions into a real person’s mouth unfairly alters the perception of who they really were. This backlash raises ethical questions about biopic directors’ creative responsibility.
Read More:‘Barbie’ vs ‘Oppenheimer’ Box Office Earning Comparisons: Christopher Nolan Made One Huge Blunder While Going Against Margot Robbie’s Movie
Murder Scene Labeled Slanderous
In the film,Cillian Murphy‘sOppenheimercharacter tries to poison a colleague. But Oppenheimer’s grandson insists there’s no evidence any such murder attempt occurred. He argues depicting it falsely portrays the scientist as homicidal.
#Oppenheimer’s grandson really liked the film — except the part with the poison apple 🍏
“There’s no record of him trying to kill somebody. That’s a really serious accusation … There’s not a single enemy or friend of Robert Oppenheimer who heard that during his life and…pic.twitter.com/RRNnFMAgT9
— Culture Crave 🍿 (@CultureCrave)June 27, 2025
Speaking to Time magazine this week, Charles Oppenheimer said,
“The part I like the least is this poison apple reference, which was a problem in ‘American Prometheus,'”said Charles Oppenheimer.“If you read ‘American Prometheus’ carefully enough, the authors say, ‘We don’t really know if it happened.’ There’s no record of him trying to kill somebody.”
Oppenheimer’s grandson added:
“That’s a really serious accusation and it’s historical revision. There’s not a single enemy or friend of Robert Oppenheimer who heard that during his life and considered it to be true.”
Charles Oppenheimer went on to say that he “definitely would have removed the apple thing,”but can’t imagine giving advice to Nolan, who he called an “expert” and a “genius.”
The family says this wholly fabricated murder plot grossly misrepresents Oppenheimer’s character. They argue such severe false allegations could forever alter public perception of the physicist’s life story.
Read More:Another Controversy for Christopher Nolan’s ‘Oppenheimer’ as Reports Claim Director Failed to Credit 80% of VFX Crew
Creative License Defended by Filmmakers
Director Christopher Nolan defended his right to take creative liberties in portraying the complex man behind the atomic bomb. He said dramatizing Oppenheimer’s inner turmoil requires some imagination, but is not meant as slander.
The director maintains the fictional murder scene serves a narrative purpose in illustrating Oppenheimer’s psychological distress over his creation’s deadly consequences. Nolan believes adding this drama is protected creative expression.
Read More:“We had s*x in the car”: Oppenheimer Star Cillian Murphy Found an Innovative Way to Break Ice With Brad Pitt’s $321M Movie Co-Star in Flop Film That Got 17% Rating
Legacy Hanging in the Balance
Criticism over Oppenheimer’s fictionalized version of events sparks renewed debate over ethical boundaries for biopics. As film blurs fact and fiction, the real Oppenheimer’s merit risks being tarnished by Hollywood’s take.
Historians worry that depicting Oppenheimer as murderous could permanently alter perceptions of the scientist, overshadowing his actual achievements with false controversies.
Read More:“That’s a really serious accusation”: Oppenheimer Faces Another Setback as Scientist’s Grandson Accuses Movie of Slander After Florence Pugh’s Controversial S*x Scene
The furious backlash over Oppenheimer’s fictional murder scene highlights the power of biopics to potentially rewrite history. Directors must balance creative storytelling with the duty of preserving real reputations.
Source:Twitter
Manasvi Dwivedi
Articles Published :41
Manasvi S Dwivedi is an enthusiastic writer at FandomWire. She started writing at the tender age of 5 and slowly it turned to something she enjoyed the most. She owns three books under her name and proudly calls herself the ‘Instagram Poet’.Apart from her work desk, you will find her writing letters to the moon and sky.
